Yuri 12/30/2020 1199
What active and interesting debates do fishermen have about what is better in traditional fishing – bottom tackle based on a spinning rod or feeder equipment?
Recently, bottom tackle has become increasingly popular, and accordingly, new topics for debate and questions are brewing.
Let's look at the issue of fishing using the first and second methods, and which one is better - you decide for yourself.
If you dive a little into history, you can understand that initially the bottom tackle was presented in the form of a weight that was attached to the very end of the fishing line, and a little higher there were hooks. This is how they mainly caught fish that come in schools. These include, for example, roach, herring, and others. With such fishing, the fishermen could only hope that they had found a really good “fishy” place, and that the fish themselves did not mind eating. Nothing was said about bait.
In fact, now you can find a lot of debate on forums about the fact that if you attach a feeder to the donk, then it will turn out to be a feeder tackle. Some argue that this is not true, because there must be a feeder on both the donk and the feeder, otherwise you will only have to rely on luck. It turns out that this is the same thing? No. Let's figure it out.
Donka and feeder - history
Initially, the bottom tackle was a weight tightly attached to the end of the fishing line, above which leashes with hooks were tied. Currently, this option is used only in fishing to catch fish moving in schools - herring, smelt, roach, etc. There is no alarm installed here at all, and the bite is detected visually or by touch by the twitching of the fishing line. The fisherman’s main hope in this case rests on a successfully found place and the desire of the fish to get enough. We are not talking about bait.
The above equipment found its development in carp fishing, when the sinker is also tightly attached, but is already a modern functional product. There is only one leash, with a very sharp hook on a hair rig, which hooks the fish as soon as it takes the bait and starts moving. A heavy sinker weighing at least 40 grams ensures reliable hooking.
A type of donka is “rubber band”. Here, in general, a fisherman can do without a rod, the load is very heavy, first a thin rubber is attached to it, and only then comes the main line with several leashes.
Now let’s look at how a feeder differs from a donkey for each element of the tackle.
Feeder rod. Why do I fish with a feeder?
Greetings. In this video I talk about the most important thing in any fishing - the rod
.
Fishing rods
What confuses me in the description is some crazy weight - Feeder rod Okuma SPM FEEDER 3. I’ve never used this one. What is the difference between a feeder rod and a carp rod? Feeder rod Salmo Elite TARGET FEEDER 3. They just say it doesn’t deserve attention, there are better options for the money. You better voice your budget and what method you want to catch carp. Classic feeder fishing or “method” fishing. Because the rods will be completely different. What is the difference between a feeder and a longer rod? Another important difference between a feeder and a rod. I just want to say that the name is just a commercial component that rarely conveys the characteristics of the rod. I think any relatively universal fishing rods will do; it’s difficult to name a specific model without knowing the budget. What is the difference between a carp rod and a feeder rod as a signaling device? If it’s more budget-friendly, then I would still advise Mikado Tachibana, or get one from Poland. Where are our public paysites with kg fish? Posted June 4, IMHO, it’s not a stick that catches, it’s the fisherman who catches. But if we ask the question - a feeder or a carp fish - then a feeder is better - a more universal tackle is suitable for simple bottom fishing as well. The only disadvantage of a feeder up to 80 grams will be the inability to force fishing when fishing in snags. What is the difference between a carp rod and a feeder rod? And in everything else, a well-tuned freak will rule. Igor, it’s clear that he’s a fisherman, I don’t lose sight of such capital instincts! Well, doesn’t length matter? After all, with 4.5 meters it is easier to pull out the hold. I can’t say for sure which test I will take? I ask for advice to decide on the conditions of our Nizhny Novgorod fishing, according to your experience!
Rod
For donkeys, special requirements are placed on rods for carp fishing only - they must be capable of catching 10-kilogram or more trophies. For simple rigs, any spinning rod will do. Even lightweight (“light”) forms can be adapted for catching crucian carp or bream by placing a weight of up to 20 grams or a particularly light weight plastic feeder.
For feeder fishing you need a high-tech fishing rod that has two properties:
- strength sufficient to fish out large fish weighing up to 5 kg;
- ease, so that the angler does not get tired from many casts.
In addition, such forms are necessarily equipped with a removable upper bend - the tip, which performs the unique function of a bite alarm.
The feeder rod is usually of the plug type and has a replaceable tip - an alarm
High demands on a feeder rod lead to high prices for quality products. But a lightweight and at the same time powerful blank can bring maximum comfort to the angler.
What is the difference between a spinning rod and a feeder rod?
Feeder and spinning rods are designed for catching fish; they have the same purpose. But, there are significant differences in the methodology and area of their use. Feeder rods and spinning rods are designed for completely different types of fishing. Feeder, after casting you can put it on the stand and wait for a bite. The spinning rod must be held in your hands at all times.
A feeder rod is much heavier and longer than a spinning rod. In addition, fishing with a spinning rod is much more active than when using a feeder. You can change the tips on the feeder, which indicate flexibility and the degree of bite; the spinning rod has no removable parts. What type of gear to choose is a purely individual question, which depends on preferences, type of fish, type of water body and financial capabilities.
What is the difference between feeder
carp fishing rod
Simply carried out long casts due to the fact that the feeder is longer. What is the difference between a feeder rod
from carp.
When choosing a rod for bottom fishing, a newbie has many questions. Light weight and easy to transport and throw. How does the feeder differ from the one included in the feeder set compared to a regular carp fishing rod? If. Feeder or carp rod? What to choose Here the choice is yours. Chekhon, pike, perch on the feeder
. Which feeder to choose for the feeder. What is the difference between carp rods and feeder rods? GoldWolf Personal page View profile Find more posts by GoldWolf All user topics. This advertising space is free. For almost every fish there is a type of rod that best performs its function.
Coil
There are no big differences here, but there are nuances. Thus, bottom fishing does not require frequent casting, so a reel is used both inertial and non-inertial. The first is rarely used in modern conditions, since it requires serious skill in preventing “beards” from the fishing line.
How to make a donka for carp with your own hands
The inertia-free one is selected based on the weight of the load being thrown. Special requirements are imposed only on those used for carp fishing - they must reel in quickly and have a powerful mechanism capable of withstanding heavy loads when fishing.
Feeders are equipped only with spinning reels, since long, frequent and accurate casts are needed. Fishing practice has developed the following criteria for choosing this element of gear:
- gear ratio in the region of 5-5.2;
- spool size – up to 4500;
- number of bearings – 5 will be enough;
- The location of the brake depends on the angler’s preferences.
The feeder reel needs to be more functional due to the many casts to come
Feeder fishing, in addition, assumes that you will have to make a lot of casts and reels of heavy equipment, so the reel mechanism must be reliable.
Bite alarm
What's the difference here? As alarms, both simple devices are used, such as bells, bells, clips on the fishing line, which visually and ringingly indicate that the fish has taken the bait, as well as electronic devices that give an audible signal about a bite. In order for the alert to work as efficiently as possible, the rod is placed perpendicular to the water's edge towards the feeding table.
The signaling device for donkey can also be pendulum - any that is not suitable for frequent casting
As already mentioned, only a flexible removable tip signals a bite on the feeder rod. They are available in varying degrees of hardness, and each has its own color. Included with one form can be 2-3 spare elbows of this kind; the connection to the main form is plug-in.
The feeder, unlike the donkey, cannot be left unattended, since the flexible tip must always be kept in sight, and distraction threatens to lose the bait without catching fish.
The feeder uses a flexible tip that acts as a bite alarm
The rod, unlike the donkey, is located almost parallel to the coastline, then the flexible signaling whip will accurately indicate the moment of the bite.
Fishing technique
The technique of fishing with a feeder and a donk has enormous differences, from the equipment itself to the work performed that needs to be done for a successful fishing outcome. Fishing with a donk is quite lazy, because it requires practically no preliminary preparation, while just preparing for fishing with a feeder can take an hour or even more.
Feeder fishing technique
First you need to prepare the bait: mix the mixture, let it brew, re-moisten the bait, push it through a sieve to saturate the bait with oxygen and make it looser.
While the bait absorbs moisture, you can begin to measure the bottom using a marker sinker. This process takes a long time, especially if you have little experience or the fishing location is unfamiliar to you.
Finding a promising location and preparing high-quality bait takes from 30 minutes to a whole hour. But even after this it’s too early to rest; the beginning of feeder fishing requires a high pace, because you need to feed the selected point.
During feeder fishing, you cannot move away from the rod, because you can only see the bite by looking at the tip of the rod.
Advantages
- Not boring fishing, constant re-casts, and with a successful set of circumstances also bites on almost every cast make fishing very exciting.
- The ability to control the progress of fishing, dose the supply of food and live components, thereby influencing the frequency of bites, scare away small fish and try to target larger ones.
Flaws
- Long preparation for the fishing process
- The need for experience in working with bait and tackle
- There is no way to move away from the rod. You have to set up camp and prepare food before fishing starts or during quiet times.
Donk fishing technique
With donka everything is much simpler, the only thing worth paying attention to is preparing the bait, but preparing it is much easier, you can not be afraid of over-moistening it, so there is no point in gradual moistening. There is also no need to force the bait through a sieve and saturate it with oxygen, since its task is to be sticky and stay tightly in the feeder.
Re-casts are performed approximately once every 15-30 minutes, so there is time to enjoy nature, slowly set up camp, and prepare food.
To identify bites, hang a bell on the tip of the rod or fishing line; this allows you to not be constantly tied to the rod, and you can calmly do other things.
Advantages
- Does not require preparatory steps
- Does not require great skill in working with gear
- Ability to step away from the rods and do other things
Flaws
- Rare bites, the need to use several rods to increase the frequency of bites and the number of fish caught.
- There is no possibility to change fishing tactics, there is no possibility to change the dosage of food or the ability to supply a live component.
Feeder
Feeders for donks are not required, but if used, they are most often in the form of a spring sliding along a fishing line with a weight on the axis. The bait is stuffed into coils, a leash with a hook is knitted below or on both sides of the feeder.
Bottom tackle option with a spiral weighted feeder and two hooks
If a simple load is used, then the fisherman needs to feed the selected place. The accuracy here is low and this is the main disadvantage of this method of fishing. But if there is a shortage of bait, this property can turn into an advantage.
For the feeder, container-type feeders are needed so that when the equipment is pulled up, the bait leaves them freely. It is because of this feeder that the tackle got its name (in English “to feed” - feed).
Fishing principles
The principle of fishing determines whether you are engaged in feeder fishing or fishing with a classic donk. The presence of the feeder form itself does not determine the type of fishing, because it can be safely used as a classic donk.
Fishing with a feeder according to the donkey principle is called “Flat feeder”. True, instead of the usual spiral feeder, they use a method feeder; the food is pressed into it using a special mold.
Principles of feeder fishing
The essence of feeder fishing is to collect the target fish in a certain place; to do this, using a marker weight on the bottom, find a promising point, clip on it and, by frequently feeding a feeder with food to the point, create a feeding spot, the so-called “table”.
Advantages
- If the point you chose turned out to be successful and you were able to organize a high-quality “table” that could attract fish and keep it on the point, then you will begin to get bites on almost every cast. Usually such a session ends with a very good catch.
Flaws
- You risk leaving with nothing if the fishing spot is poorly chosen or the “table” is poorly organized. After all, there is often no time to look for and feed a new point.
The principle of fishing with a donk
Look for fish in different points of the water area, luring them to a feeder with inert food; such food does not crumble when the feeder falls to the bottom, but is held tightly in the feeder with a little dust. The fish, having found a feeder with food, begins to suck on it, and at this time the hook is in close proximity to the feeder or is completely recessed into it. While sucking on the feeder, the fish, unnoticed by itself, sucks in the hook.
Advantages
- Low consumption of bait mixture, since fishing will require 0.5-1 pack of bait, while feeder fishing requires two or even three times more feed.
- There is no need to waste time and effort on measuring the bottom; the ability to cast into different places of the reservoir allows you to find fish using the “poke” method.
Flaws
- You will never collect the target fish in one place; inert food simply does not wash out of the feeder and will not allow you to create a feeding spot.
- Even with good food, you have to wait quite a long time for bites, since the fish need time to find the feeder.
General observations
The feeder works better for schooling fish that can be easily collected at a certain point: bream, roach, silver bream, etc.
Donka performs well when catching fish that are more difficult to collect at the point and that like to roam the expanses of the water area: carp, crucian carp, tench, etc.
However, there are many real examples of how crucian carp and crucian carp are successfully caught on a feeder, and vice versa, with the help of a donkey you can catch good bream and other schooling fish.
Comparison results
A feeder or donk is united by one principle - fishing is carried out from the bottom using a load. This is where the similarity ends. Then there are differences - in the rod (the feeder has a more technologically advanced one), in the reel, in the equipment, and especially in the method of signaling the bite. The bottom can be equipped with a simple guard; the feeder rod is crowned with a brightly colored flexible tip, showing the moment the fish takes the bait. As a result, a feeder is a sports tackle that allows you to increase fishing speed and catch rate, but the final choice of which is better is up to the fisherman.
